ATD Blog
The Purpose of Performance Management: Redefining Aspirations
Wed May 27 2015
Content
Dissatisfaction with performance management is at an all-time high. What’s more, performance management activities such as formal goal-setting processes, mid-year and year-end reviews, and extensive rating and calibration processes cost the average organization millions of dollars annually. Yet research shows individual performance management ratings have no correlation with business unit performance.
Dissatisfaction with performance management is at an all-time high. What’s more, performance management activities such as formal goal-setting processes, mid-year and year-end reviews, and extensive rating and calibration processes cost the average organization millions of dollars annually. Yet research shows individual performance management ratings have no correlation with business unit performance.
Content
Addressing an Urgent Challenge
Addressing an Urgent Challenge
Content
In response, some organizations have begun to modernize parts of their performance management approach to drive behaviors that are critical in today’s work environment, including:
In response, some organizations have begun to modernize parts of their performance management approach to drive behaviors that are critical in today’s work environment, including:
Content
providing informal feedback
providing informal feedback
Content
setting clear expectations
setting clear expectations
Content
working collaboratively.
working collaboratively.
Content
A few very high-profile companies, including Microsoft and Adobe, have publicly and significantly changed their formal performance management processes. The majority of companies, however, are making incremental changes to performance management by taking more measured steps.
A few very high-profile companies, including Microsoft and Adobe, have publicly and significantly changed their formal performance management processes. The majority of companies, however, are making incremental changes to performance management by taking more measured steps.
Content
With so much noise in the system, and so many different strategies being held up as the example for how to transform performance management, it’s difficult to know what’s right for your organization. What should be your organization’s goal when it comes to performance management?
With so much noise in the system, and so many different strategies being held up as the example for how to transform performance management, it’s difficult to know what’s right for your organization. What should be your organization’s goal when it comes to performance management?
Content
What is the fundamental purpose of performance management?
What is the fundamental purpose of performance management?
Content
When CEB asks organizations what they use performance management for, the top answers are:
When CEB asks organizations what they use performance management for, the top answers are:
Content
making decisions about pay, promotions, or other personnel actions
making decisions about pay, promotions, or other personnel actions
Content
identifying poor performers and holding them accountable
identifying poor performers and holding them accountable
Content
providing documentation to defend against legal challenges.
providing documentation to defend against legal challenges.
Content
But when we ask organizations what performance management should achieve for them, the answers are much more aspirational:
But when we ask organizations what performance management should achieve for them, the answers are much more aspirational:
Content
help employees develop and grow
help employees develop and grow
Content
improve communication between employees and managers
improve communication between employees and managers
Content
align individual work to achieving the organization’s goals
align individual work to achieving the organization’s goals
Content
help individuals and teams perform to their highest potential.
help individuals and teams perform to their highest potential.
Content
The first list is decidedly administrative in nature, while the second reflects the desire for performance management to improve individual and organizational performance. However, performance management approaches that try to serve too many purposes will not serve any one purpose well.
The first list is decidedly administrative in nature, while the second reflects the desire for performance management to improve individual and organizational performance. However, performance management approaches that try to serve too many purposes will not serve any one purpose well.
Content
Finding the Underscoring Purpose
Finding the Underscoring Purpose
Content
Different types of decisions require different processes and criteria. For example, an employee’s annual merit increase is typically based on the organization’s budget, changes in the labor market for the specific job, the employee’s salary relative to her peers’ and her performance. In contrast, a decision about who to promote is based on performance and demonstrated potential to operate successfully at the next level.
Different types of decisions require different processes and criteria. For example, an employee’s annual merit increase is typically based on the organization’s budget, changes in the labor market for the specific job, the employee’s salary relative to her peers’ and her performance. In contrast, a decision about who to promote is based on performance and demonstrated potential to operate successfully at the next level.
Content
Ultimately, organizations must align their performance management approach with the purpose they most want to achieve. If the fundamental purpose of performance management is to help organizations maximize productivity by enabling employees to perform to their potential , the approach should be designed to accomplish the following three critical goals:
Ultimately, organizations must align their performance management approach with the purpose they most want to achieve. If the fundamental purpose of performance management is to help organizations maximize productivity by enabling employees to perform to their potential, the approach should be designed to accomplish the following three critical goals:
Content
Enable employees to align their efforts in a manner that contributes most to the organization’s goals.
Enable employees to align their efforts in a manner that contributes most to the organization’s goals.
Content
Equip employees with guideposts to monitor behavior and results and make adjustments in real time as needed to maximize performance.
Equip employees with guideposts to monitor behavior and results and make adjustments in real time as needed to maximize performance.
Content
Help employees identify and remove barriers to performance.
Help employees identify and remove barriers to performance.
Content
There is no single best design, but all organizations will realize the value of performance management if they 1) define the objectives they are trying to achieve and 2) focus squarely on the performance management practices and, especially, the behaviors that matter most in driving improved performance.
There is no single best design, but all organizations will realize the value of performance management if they 1) define the objectives they are trying to achieve and 2) focus squarely on the performance management practices and, especially, the behaviors that matter most in driving improved performance.
Content
Editor’s Note: The next installment of this blog series will examine the three shifts that companies must make to significantly improve performance management in today’s dynamic, complex work environment. You can learn more about how industry leaders build and sustain high-performance cultures at cebglobal.com .
Editor’s Note: The next installment of this blog series will examine the three shifts that companies must make to significantly improve performance management in today’s dynamic, complex work environment. You can learn more about how industry leaders build and sustain high-performance cultures at cebglobal.com.
Content
Check out similar articles: Your Employees Hate Your Performance Review
Check out similar articles: Your Employees Hate Your Performance Review